MVP of the year 2019 goes to my immune system for somehow keeping me healthy despite many months of working with pediatric patients and patients hospitalized for infections of all sorts.

my notes on medicine, taking care of others, and living a life of compassion
MVP of the year 2019 goes to my immune system for somehow keeping me healthy despite many months of working with pediatric patients and patients hospitalized for infections of all sorts.

It’s difficult for me to judge if my dislike of certain rotations through medical specialties/sub-specialties comes from a genuine dislike of the type of work required for the specialty or if it’s simply a reflection of my dislike for 1) the faculty I work with in the specialty, 2) the specialties’ working conditions, or 3) more broadly the ecology of the healing environment.
The interpersonal dynamic in the emergency department at one particular hospital where I work is an example worth highlighting. Physicians I work with there have been less than welcoming and sometimes even outright condescending toward me. The one that was actually kind to me and helped me try to learn something new during one of my shifts also spent half of the time on shift talking with the other physicians about finances and how big their retirement funds are and/or gossiping about one of their colleagues who I happen to have as a professor (and who I happen to find is a very kind and generous teacher). That dampened my respect for the whole group of them, unfortunately. I enjoy the work of emergency medicine (figuring out what the diagnosis is for any individual who walks into the ED), but the work environment and the personalities it seems to attract are less than appealing.
On a different note, my pediatric outpatient faculty were some of the kindest, most generous, and most flexible physicians I’ve met thus far. They openly valued families (including their own!) as much as they valued their profession, and their priority was always establishing comfort, honesty, and education in their relationship with patients and their patients’ parents/guardians. They were active members of patient advocacy organizations and legal-medical partnerships. They seemed happy in a way that seemed qualitatively different from other physicians I’d met. I admired them.
Let’s take part of my pediatrics clerkship as another example. Specifically, let’s examine my week-long rotation in the newborn nursery. I worked in a closet. Literally. When not examining a baby in a patient room or in the incubators of the nursery, I spent hours reading, typing notes, and studying in a closet. The workroom for trainees and students is a 12 ft x 12 ft former equipment storage closet that’s been converted into a workroom. We worked at computers and desks stuffed into a very small windowless space. No better way to go a little crazy when working a 12 hour shift when your home-base is a closet. Unfortunately, the physicians’ workroom is only slightly more pleasant, as it is also an oversized closet with no windows that happens to have soft lamp lighting rather than harsh fluorescent overhead lighting. I think this example is so valuable because it illuminates a small piece of medicine that I find rarely talked about: physicians and trainees as capital. The political economy of medicine is not divorced from capitalism and its exploitative necessities. This is a recurrent theme of my clerkships that likely deserves its own separate post.
Ah, and the best example for last: my primary care clerkship site. Now, my primary care preceptor truly deserves a post of his own; I can already see the title of that piece of writing, in fact. It would look something like, “Where the #MeToo Movement Meets Medicine,” and as you can probably guess, it would be an essay about the intersection of mysogyny, toxic masculinity, and the practice of primary care medicine. I won’t launch into a full analysis of my experience right now, but allow me to dive into a few observational sketches regarding my experience. My preceptor is a middle-aged man who operates with many unchallenged assumptions, theories, and “truths” about the world. For example, he believes male ObGyns are better than female ObGyns and will only refer his female patients to male ObGyns. He believes part-time physicians are phonies and care more about going to “yoga class” than “doing something that has merit in the world”; he criticizes people (women) who choose to be part-time physicians in order to also raise a family. He also believes that wearing gloves while examining men’s genitals is a reflection of prejudice on the part of the physician (or in my case, a trainee), yet he purports to always wear gloves when examining women’s genitalia. He also gives unsolicited advice to me about my appearance or about what I should do with my life. And don’t even get me started about me being “pimped” (med training lingo for “quizzed”, “grilled”, “roasted”) in front of patients in their exam rooms that he likes to do…
Beyond these discrete examples of his unchecked beliefs and his own biases, he operates his primary care practice in a cultural milieu that is worth pointing out. His patients are almost exclusively older people aged 40+, and his clinic looks to be straight out of the nineties or the early aughts. I don’t believe this is a coincidence, because he operates under an old-school type of doctor-patient relationship that is ultimately paternalistic and not necessarily keeping pace with interpersonal/political/social advances in medicine. A few examples: He prescribes unsolicited marriage counseling, personal psychological assessments, and life advice to men (and maybe women too, but I’ve never seen that). He tells his patients what to do without establishing the patients’ goals for their health/life, and he operates with full deference and thus without any challenge from his patients. In short, he does not practice shared decision making and he is often not forthcoming with his patients in regard to why he is prescribing certain medications or why he is ordering certain blood tests or radiologic studies. This is a kind of model of “doctoring” that puts physicians in a place of extreme privilege and endows them a font of authoritarian power from which to unceasingly draw. And ultimately it robs patients of their autonomy.
While I have absolute confidence that this particular doctor is operating with his patients’ best interests in mind, I hope to never be like him when I am a licensed physician. I guess that means I’m having a good learning experience at this clerkship site?
Overall, my clerkship experiences thus far have been galvanizing. I don’t particularly like any specialty I’ve seen so far, but not necessarily because I don’t enjoy the work that the specialty entails. I believe it’s due to the toxicity of the environment, culture, and interpersonal dynamics I see in each specialty. I want to desperately do something radically different than all that I’ve seen thus far. Which leads me to a challenge: how will I be such that I will not re-create these problematic patterns in my own practice?
spotted in the hospital:
She had gone to a voodoo priest for help in interpreting this dream. Each of the lumps had significance, said the priest. They represented ‘the three mysteries,’ and to be cured she would have to travel to a clinic where doctors ‘worked with both hands’ (this term suggesting that they would have to understand both natural and supernatural illness).
– Paul Farmer, “An Anthropology of Structural Violence” in Partner to the Poor: A Paul Farmer Reader
I feel so conflicted some days about my medical training because I have yet to reconcile a personal tension that is floating on the surface of my mind.
I feel that my cultural values and spiritual beliefs are not “allowed” in this culture of medicine in which I am being trained, and that makes it hard to envision how I can be what I’m being taught a “doctor” is. This task feels daunting, as it requires that I map my own way mostly unassisted. Surely someone has come before me on this path… but where are they? Who are my mentors?
I’m reminded of a young Hmong woman, Mrs. W, who I met while on my internal medicine clerkship. Mrs. W is a woman who came into the hospital in a state of crisis: hemorrhage. Surgery saved her from internally bleeding to the point of hemorrhagic shock, and for that she is grateful. But now science, by way of the various teams of physicians caring for her, cannot explain why she is experiencing a whole host of issues including hemolytic anemia almost a week after her surgery. Despite throwing every analytical test at the problem– everything just short of a bone marrow biopsy, I should say– and finding no compelling explanations, there are no answers for Mrs. W and her husband. After weeks in the hospital and little relief from her situation, she told our team of trainees and students supervised by the attending physician that she wanted to go home to consult with the shaman with whom her family calls upon in times of sickness. She said that her husband believed that the recent passing of his parents might be the reason she was getting more sick; it might be because the parents were trying to communicate something to her or her husband. The shaman, she explained, would be able to pass along messages and instruct her and her husband in what offerings to give.
This moved me. Here was a patient to whom I could relate! I deeply wanted to swap notes: What it feels like to be held by your rituals and ceremony. What dreams show of the spirit world. What songs or chants you sing in praise or in prayer. What an adequate offering looks like. What healing the spirit, mind, and body feels like, looks like, sounds like, and smells like.
Maybe my work as a physician is meant to be among other people who hold spiritual beliefs about healing. Perhaps this is what Mrs. W taught me. I‘d like to heal with both hands.
“Grief is not a condition to be diagnosed and treated. Feeling down and blue and a bit hopeless is not a disease that needs to be cured by consumption, whether that consumption is of material goods or new inner states. A broken heart is pure and complete on its own, filled with Integrity, intelligence, and life. It need not be mended nor transformed into something else. It is the vehicle by which the Poetry of your life will flow.”
Matt Licata – The Path is Everywhere
Sometimes I wonder if I want to help heal others partly because I desperately want to heal myself but don’t know how. I also wonder if my own “brokenness” (the parts in me that cry out for healing, for mending, for setting) is what makes me so good at healing others– or rather, so willing to heal others and take time to be with them through that journey to balance and integration.
I used to believe there was some better version of myself out there somewhere beyond my grief, my sadness, my anger, my loneliness, my hurt, my self-doubt — all these feelings that make my conditioned sense of inadequacy all the more pronounced. Lately I’ve started realizing that there is no “out there somewhere.” It’s all just part of me, and that’s ok. My broken heart makes me who I am, and it makes my healing work strong, thorough, personal.
According to one of my attending pediatric physicians, there are four rules to remember about wards:
🙂
While kids are adorable and helping them get well (and helping their parents find peace) is very gratifying, I don’t think pediatrics is for me. I find the process of working with “two” patients– kids and their parent(s)– to be disconcerting; it leaves me feeling scattered. I also feel strangely when not able to build a good rapport with a child due to lack of time. I want to have deeper relationships with kids that I feel the hospital doesn’t afford me. Perhaps outpatient pediatrics will be different.
A reflection from week 1 of the IM rotation
Mr. H had an acute kidney injury. No one trusted Mr. H when he said he didn’t smoke meth recreationally and that he accidentally smoked meth the night before on a cigarette he bummed from a friend. No one trusted him when he said he had relentless chest and neck pain on hospital day 1, day 2, or even day 3. (“It’s just because you’ve been vomiting and have sore muscles now,” he was told.) When discussing his case, many of the physicians working on his case scoffed and jeered at his story, his complaints. Sly smiles, dripping with derision, smeared on the young doctors’ faces. “They’re all liars,” a resident expressed, shaking his head in disapproval. “Why do you say that?” I asked. “Because drug addicts are liars. They don’t want to admit that they use drugs, and they won’t tell the full story. I learn more about these people by reading their charts when they arrive in the ED than I do from talking to them.”
By hospital day 3, none of the physicians wanted to spend more than a few minutes checking up on him in the morning; the intern stayed long enough to ask if Mr. H experienced any more nausea, vomiting, and anuria overnight. When Mr. H began to talk about his chest and neck pain, the intern left the room. “I have other people to see this morning, so I’m going to go,” he told me quietly before he slipped out from the room as Mr. H was talking. I stayed behind to ask Mr. H to elaborate on his pain, its character and location exactly. I wasn’t convinced that he simply had sore muscles, despite the fact that when I pressed on his chest, he winced in pain as if his chest was very sore– something that made sore muscles seem likely. Upon asking, he described his pain as sharp, internal, and accompanied by “crackling” or “bubbles” in his neck. I felt his neck. Under my fingertips, his skin danced as if it was resting on a water bed made of crumpled tissue paper. It audibly crackled. I may be a spring chicken, but I know that that finding on physical exam was anything but normal. I presented his case during rounds, to the mild disinterest of the doctors on my team (only interested in the part about whether or not he could be discharged that day), and noted that I’d like the attending to check on his neck because I found it to be strangely crackly. “Was it crepitus?” the attending asked suddenly looking more alarmed. I thought to myself, “Crepitus… What is crepitus…?” as I looked at her blankly. “Um, I’m not sure I know what that is.” She said she’d check it out.
He ended up having a pneumomediastinum likely due to an esophageal perforation that caused air to become trapped in his chest and neck– a finding that is termed “crepitus.”
I was lauded by my attending for my finding. I started hearing from other senior doctors in the hospital that they were also impressed with the finding. One of my later attendings told me that I should feel proud for performing a thorough physical exam, paying attention to the patient’s concerns, and finding the sign of his pneumomediastinum (a pathological situation that could’ve been much more consequential for him if his perforation had not closed up spontaneously!). “This isn’t something many of the residents would do; they’re too busy to stop and perform a thorough exam.” He continued, “Let this be a lesson to all of us.”
Perhaps this experience is not simply about taking time for patients, taking time to be thorough or to follow-up on complaints or odd findings, to not anchor ourselves to the easiest explanations. Perhaps this is also a lesson in trust, non-judgement, humility, generosity, and compassion. What greater gift can we give to someone than our time, attention, and thoughtfulness?
On that note. To all the addicts, people experiencing homeless, and those who are otherwise considered deplorable in the eyes of others: you matter. I hope I never stop trusting you when you say you’re in pain. I vow to maintain a sense of generosity of spirit and attention with every patient no matter who they are.
The attending physician on my team and I had a good farewell chat today. He asked me for my critiques of our workflow and structure as an internal medicine team. I was pleasantly surprised to be able to open up to him about what I find remarkably troubling about the hospital (the windowless rooms, the lack of green spaces for workers and patients/families, the silo-ing of departments, the lack of time afforded to residents/interns/students to spend with patients after rounds end, the inefficiency of inter-team communications, the constant deluge of new information and feeling like it’s impossible to learn it all so quickly.) It was a good conversation. He offered me a few take-home points for my time moving forward on the IM service. Here are some notes I took:
+ Absolve yourself of self-judgement regarding how much you “must know” about the minute details regarding diseases/medications/physiology (in regard particularly to board exams). Instead, deepen your care for your patients ; then, you’ll be able to go find any nuanced, detailed information about their disease process/medications you “don’t know” when you need it. Don’t get lost in the scientific details and then forget to take time to also know your patients.
+ Healthcare systems, including our hospital, do not exist outside capitalist ideology. Doctors, nurses, social workers, and pharmacists are all workers in a very traditional, capitalist sense. I found this a refreshing reminder. Analyzing my time at the hospital with more of an anti-capitalist lens regarding the structures and functions of the workplace and how that intersects with the production of capital is helpful for me.
+ Start each day with an objective in mind. What can I learn, observe, witness, investigate each day? Take advantage of time in the hospital as something I may never have again (since it’s looking like a hospital is not my ideal future work environment…).
+ Keep dreaming big. What could hospitals look like if they centered their work around people rather than profits? Make this part of your work. There is no need to accept normative models as necessary in the future of healthcare.
+ We see people in the hospital at a breaking point in their disease process. There is value in following their disease up-stream, to the time before they emerged in the hospital, to find out the roots of illness. What can I do about up-stream causes of disease? This is a rich place of inquiry for me.
internal medicine clerkship week 4: a few notes
“I am thankful for small mercies. I compared notes with one of my friends who expects everything of the universe, and is disappointed when anything is less than the best, and I found that I begin at the other extreme, expecting nothing, and am always full of thanks for moderate goods.”
~ Ralph Waldo Emerson
There are many things I could write about, but right now I’m hung up on something. The work of hospital medicine has left me feeling the opposite of inspired. And that reminds me that if I feel uninspired (and then frustrated and indignant that I’m not inspired), then perhaps I was operating under the expectation that this clerkship would be inspiring, meaningful, profound, etc. or worse: operating under the expectation that I deserve to be inspired. An unfortunate …albeit liberating… realization, this is.
“When we run away from boredom, we are running away from ourselves.”
~ Josh Korda, published on Lion’s Roar
I thought that I would– on some level– feel passionately about internal medicine. Instead, I feel whatever the opposite of passion is. Dispassionate. No, that’s not the right word, because I definitely don’t feel any sense of impartial feelings that would be suggested by the word “dispassionate.” I feel something more akin to being restless… uninterested… anxious… averse… bored.
I’m doing exactly what I want to be doing: serving people on their road to recovery, and yet I feel this simmering pot of feelings (not-inspired, disinterest, restless aversion, boredom) inside of me. Where are these feelings coming from? What story am I telling myself?
a boulder, a hill, a man
“Kierkegaard and Camus saw Sisyphus — the Greek figure who was destined to push a boulder up a hill forever — as a potential hero. There was great liberation there, they said, because rather than constantly chasing the new, the stimulating, the novel, Sisyphus was given the opportunity to let go of wanting life to be different than it is, wanting to escape old age, sickness, death, frustration, sadness, loneliness: all the stuff that is life. His unique position allowed him to confront the baseline of his existence.”
Josh Korda, published on Lion’s Roar
Maybe my internal medicine (hospital) clerkship experience is like the boulder Sisyphus pushed up his hill every day, non-stop. If so, then I, like Sisphyus, am being presented with “the opportunity to let go of wanting life to be different than it is, wanting to escape” from all the things I find abhorrent about my day-to-day existence right now. This resonates with me.
The volume of sensory information I am presented with each day is unreal: the smells (oh my goodness, the smells…), the groans and sighs and (yes, sometimes) screams, the deep shades of red that is blood, the texture of edematous skin, the tangle of lines and tubes and drains emerging from flesh and interfacing with a machine, the incessant clicks and beeps of telemetry and oximetry monitors, the awful sight of dismemberment and disfigurement due to accident or disease.
The volume of information I am presented with is similarly unreal: eponyms and Latin words and acronyms and phrases and medication names and dosage values and reference ranges and lab values and comorbidities and pre-test probabilities and more. Imagine these things tumbling from the mouths of my attending physicians and residents; I scoop them up off the floor or the table and collect what I can in lines of epic scrawl in my little pocket sized notebook, but inevitably the words overflow the pages and some things become lost in the fog that is my mind after a few hours of this cascade of information. The daily intellectual onslaught feels more pleasant to me, despite however overwhelming it can be. It contains tools. It all feels meaningful because I choose to believe that it is information that will somehow serve me later when I work independently with my own patients. I enjoy investigating on my own time the various tid-bits I scoop up. It’s a welcome distraction from the hospital itself, from the patients themselves.
A word or two about the built environment and the structure of hospital work: There are no windows in the physicians’ workrooms. Big hollow boxes filled with computers and the chatter of patient care coordination happening over the phone. There are no outside patio spaces or courtyards in which one can step outside and take a break. Some days, I feel the sun on my skin only when stepping far enough into a patient’s room to stand in the patch of sunlight coming through their window. Speaking of breaks: there is no structured break time. Lunch is expected to be eaten while listening to a physician lecture about a specific topic; I digest my food while I digest the nuance of emergent hyperkalemic medical management, acid-base disturbances, congestive heart failure, bacterial meningitis. I wait to leave the hospital until someone above me in rank tells me it’s a good time to leave, because that’s the expectation of me.
Sometimes, I get home and just feel like crying. And then there are days where I feel pretty good. There are the small blessings of the hospital: the extreme kindness of a nurse going out of their way to lend me a pair of scrubs. The elderly woman dying of heart failure who I check up on; the last few times I saw her, I would go into her room to see how she was doing, and she’d reach out for my hand. She’d hold it tight and nod back off to sleep. I also find gratification in sticking up for a patient of mine in the face of prejudice, ambivalence, disregard sent their way. Ruffling enough feathers to finally get traction on something a patient needs that is important to them but may seem trivial to others buoys me on some days. A few days ago, the doctor I was with told a patient point-blank that he had diabetes and would die from a stroke or heart attack or kidney disease unless he changed his life. He was in his late 20’s. I’m barely older than he is. I held his hand and we talked about what diabetes means and we cried together. That experience reminded me of why I decided to practice medicine.
Yes, on some level, I feel a sense of discomfort at the hospital because it feels impersonal, mechanical, procedural, sterile, inefficient, uncreative, soulless– all things I do not believe the built human environment must be or even should be. But I am more troubled by the way I find myself shying away from the awfulness of the hospital; I want to avoid the human horrors– suffering, disgusting sensory experiences, infectious diseases, pitiful states of being, unjust treatment of some patients, the way that people can be so mean and hurtful to one another when stressed or insecure– and ignore them. The reality of human suffering and diseases and dying and death is not a mutable phenomenon. And if at all mutable, it most definitely is not over the next four weeks of my internal medicine clerkship. I suppose it only makes sense then that I’d be increasingly uninspired, bored, restless, and averse as I face this unmutable reality of existence everyday for more hours each day than I’d like to admit. It’s also no wonder that I would feel such restlessness, aversion, and agitation in the face of feeling the desire to take away others’ suffering and being totally powerless to do so. On some level, I need to let go of my desire for things to be different. Over the four weeks I have left on this clerkship, I will be pushing a rock up a hill each day. And in that experience, I vow to commit myself fully. There is a lesson to be found tucked inside my lack of inspiration, my frustration, my boredom.